2021-11-29 06:47:18 BERY Berry Global
11/29/21 11/2906:47 11/29/2106:47 | Ancora urges Berry Global to commit to review of strategic alternativesAncora Holdings Group announced that it has sent a letter to Berry Global Group, Inc.'s Board of Directors. The company said, "Ancora Holdings Group is a shareholder of Berry Global Group, with ownership of approximately one percent of the Company's outstanding shares. We believe Berry has a high-quality portfolio of packaging products and a unique value proposition to offer the global manufacturing sector. We also believe Berry has a capable management team that deserves credit for driving meaningful sales growth and earnings improvements in recent years. However, despite these tailwinds, Berry has been a chronic underperformer that perpetually trades at a significant discount to the broader market, relevant indices and packaging peers. In our view, it is time for the Board of Directors to take real action to address the impediments to value creation that have compounded at Berry. We deem Wednesday afternoon's announcement of $50 million in planned share repurchases to be an insult to investors. Not only is the size of the accelerated share repurchase transaction wholly insufficient, but the Board did not even increase its existing authorization. As total shareholder returns have lagged in recent years, the Board has repeatedly failed to establish an accretive capital allocation policy and seize opportunities to monetize non-core real estate assets. It is now necessary to initiate a comprehensive review of strategic alternatives, including a full sale or go-private transaction. We have spent significant energy and time analyzing Berry's operational and financial performance since Tom Salmon became Chief Executive Officer in February 2017. Mr. Salmon has presided over a 113.4% increase in annual revenues, an 83.8% increase in annual EBITDA and, most importantly, a 134.3% increase in diluted earnings per share. Regrettably, these results have been accompanied by a paltry 29.7% share price uptick during his nearly five-year tenure.1 Additionally, we remain concerned by Berry's acquisition track record and leverage philosophy. Shareholders have historically suffered as the Company, which was previously saddled with immense debt, pursued deals with excessively high leverage ratios, causing its shares to trade at an acute discount. But even now that the Company's leverage ratio is within its target range, its shares still continue to underperform the market. This suggests to us that Berry's persistent valuation discount is linked to the risk of the Board continuing to allocate capital to acquisitions, rather than simply being the result of the Company's leverage ratio. A credible capital allocation policy that prioritizes returning cash to shareholders could be one remedy for Berry's punishing valuation gap.We believe Ancora is not the only shareholder that feels the Board should commit to reviewing its existing strategy relative to alternatives. In recent months, we have had conversations with a number of fellow shareholders who expressed their own concerns about Berry's share price stagnation and valuation discount. Certain shareholders, including us, now believe they may be best served by seeing the Company sold to one of the many well-capitalized financial sponsors and strategic buyers in the marketplace. A review of relevant and comparable acquisitions indicates shareholders could receive $100 per share or more in value via a sale. It is unclear whether the current Board has a viable plan for unlocking that type of value on a standalone basis any time soon..As noted, we believe the Board needs to promptly commence a review of strategic alternatives. The review should be communicated publicly so that shareholders can see that the Board is taking its fiduciary duties seriously. We believe that a strong Board that is in tune with its shareholders would actively address the concerns of engaged shareholders. Playing hide-the-ball with information on the direction of the Company after a prolonged period of stagnation runs counter to what we believe are sound governance practices maintained by a well-functioning Board. First and foremost, we believe the Board should consider repurchasing additional shares with Berry's ample free cash flow and capital on hand. In light of the Company's strong profitability, it is particularly well-positioned to buy back stock at current levels. Not only would a large and ongoing repurchase program be accretive for Berry, but it would also send a strong message to investors that leadership has confidence in the business going forward. We suggest that the Board immediately announces an expansion of its repurchase authorization to $1 billion. Another logical step is a sale-leaseback transaction. If Berry is concerned about balance sheet flexibility and having sufficient cash to fund strategic growth, then it should consider funding share repurchases through a sale-leaseback transaction that will generate significant cash. We estimate Berry has up to $2 billion in real estate value currently tied up on its balance sheet, and that a transaction with the right buyer could provide the Company with nearly 20% of its market capitalization in cash. Seizing this opportunity would allow the Board to quickly upsize its $400 million "opportunistic" repurchase authorization to $1 billion or more in size, while still retaining capital for prudent investments. Lastly, we believe the Board owes it to long-suffering shareholders to evaluate a sale of the Company or a go-private transaction. Ancora, in particular, views this step as an absolute necessity given the public market's unwillingness to properly value Berry. Rather than taking action to aggressively combat the low valuation multiple, the Board has spent years allowing management to run the Company like a private business with an ultra-long-term investment horizon, translating to a lack of return of capital to shareholders. In light of the aforementioned factors, the Board should hire a qualified investment bank to run a market test. Our own analysis of comparable transactions indicates Berry could fetch a valuation of $100 per share or more via a sale." |
---|
Recommendations
|
Aedifica price target lowered to EUR 74 from EUR 93 at Barclays »
12:46 07/05/22 07/0512:46 07/05/2212:46
AEDFF
Aedifica
Barclays analyst Celine… Story temporarily locked. ShowHide Related Items >><<
|
Hot Stocks
|
Duddell Street, FiscalNote announce effectiveness of registration statement »
12:45 07/05/22 07/0512:45 07/05/2212:45
DSAC
Duddell Street Acquisition
FiscalNote
Duddell Street… Story temporarily locked. |
Options
|
MongoDB call volume above normal and directionally bullish »
12:45 07/05/22 07/0512:45 07/05/2212:45
MDB
MongoDB
Bullish option flow… Story temporarily locked. ShowHide Related Items >><<
|
Periodicals
|
U.S. pushing Netherlands to ban ASML chips to China, Bloomberg says »
12:42 07/05/22 07/0512:42 07/05/2212:42
ASML
ASML
The U.S. is pushing the… Story temporarily locked. ShowHide Related Items >><<
|
Hot Stocks
|
Infinite Reality, ReKTGlobal announce close of $470M acquisition deal »
12:37 07/05/22 07/0512:37 07/05/2212:37
UUU
Universal Security Instruments
Infinite Realty announced… Story temporarily locked. ShowHide Related Items >><<
|
Options
|
Trip.com put volume heavy and directionally bearish »
12:35 07/05/22 07/0512:35 07/05/2212:35
TCOM
Trip.com Group
Bearish flow noted in… Story temporarily locked. ShowHide Related Items >><<
|
Recommendations
|
Russel Metals price target lowered to C$34 from C$40 at Stifel »
12:33 07/05/22 07/0512:33 07/05/2212:33
RUSMF
Russel Metals
Stifel analyst Ian… Story temporarily locked. ShowHide Related Items >><<
|
Recommendations
|
Georg Fischer price target lowered to CHF 71 from CHF 77.50 at UBS »
12:32 07/05/22 07/0512:32 07/05/2212:32
FCHRF
Georg Fischer
UBS analyst Joern Iffert… Story temporarily locked. |
Recommendations
|
Ontex Group price target lowered to EUR 9.50 from EUR 10.50 at UBS »
12:31 07/05/22 07/0512:31 07/05/2212:31
ONXXF
Ontex Group
UBS analyst Charles Eden… Story temporarily locked. ShowHide Related Items >><<
|
Recommendations
|
Traton price target lowered to EUR 22 from EUR 30 at UBS »
12:30 07/05/22 07/0512:30 07/05/2212:30
TRATF
Traton
UBS analyst Guillermo… Story temporarily locked. ShowHide Related Items >><<
|
Options
|
JetBlue call volume above normal and directionally bullish »
12:25 07/05/22 07/0512:25 07/05/2212:25
JBLU
JetBlue
Bullish option flow… Story temporarily locked. ShowHide Related Items >><<
|
Recommendations
|
Daimler Truck price target lowered to EUR 35 from EUR 38 at Morgan Stanley »
12:21 07/05/22 07/0512:21 07/05/2212:21
DTRUY
Daimler Truck
Morgan Stanley analyst… Story temporarily locked. ShowHide Related Items >><<
|
Recommendations
|
AXA price target lowered to EUR 31 from EUR 33 at Morgan Stanley »
12:20 07/05/22 07/0512:20 07/05/2212:20
AXAHY
AXA
Morgan Stanley analyst… Story temporarily locked. ShowHide Related Items >><<
|
Recommendations
|
British American Tobacco price target raised to 4,000 GBp from 3,780 GBp at Morgan Stanley »
12:20 07/05/22 07/0512:20 07/05/2212:20
BTI
British American Tobacco
Morgan Stanley analyst… Story temporarily locked. ShowHide Related Items >><<
|
Recommendations
|
ABB price target raised to CHF 27.20 from CHF 27 at Morgan Stanley »
12:20 07/05/22 07/0512:20 07/05/2212:20
ABB
ABB
Morgan Stanley analyst… Story temporarily locked. ShowHide Related Items >><<
|
Recommendations
|
Societe Generale price target lowered to EUR 33 from EUR 34 at Deutsche Bank »
12:17 07/05/22 07/0512:17 07/05/2212:17
SCGLY
Societe Generale
Deutsche Bank analyst… Story temporarily locked. ShowHide Related Items >><<
|
Technical Analysis
|
NASDAQ market internals summary »
12:17 07/05/22 07/0512:17 07/05/2212:17
$NSD
NASDAQ Market Internals
Volume is above average… Story temporarily locked. ShowHide Related Items >><<
|
Recommendations
|
Amundi price target lowered to EUR 65 from EUR 89 at Deutsche Bank »
12:16 07/05/22 07/0512:16 07/05/2212:16
AMDUF
Amundi
Deutsche Bank analyst… Story temporarily locked. ShowHide Related Items >><<
|
Conference/Events
|
Copart management to meet with Stephens »
12:16 07/05/22 07/0512:16 07/05/2212:16
CPRT
Copart
Meeting to be held at… Story temporarily locked. ShowHide Related Items >><<
|
Technical Analysis
| Volume is above average… Story temporarily locked. ShowHide Related Items >><<
|
Recommendations
|
Next plc price target lowered to 6,200 GBp from 7,850 GBp at Deutsche Bank »
12:15 07/05/22 07/0512:15 07/05/2212:15
NXGPF
Next plc
Deutsche Bank analyst… Story temporarily locked. ShowHide Related Items >><<
|
Recommendations
|
Marks & Spencer price target lowered to 155 GBp from 165 GBp at Deutsche Bank »
12:15 07/05/22 07/0512:15 07/05/2212:15
MAKSY
Marks & Spencer
Deutsche Bank analyst… Story temporarily locked. ShowHide Related Items >><<
|
Options
|
ZIM Integrated Shipping Services put volume heavy and directionally bearish »
12:15 07/05/22 07/0512:15 07/05/2212:15
ZIM
ZIM Integrated
Bearish flow noted in ZIM… Story temporarily locked. ShowHide Related Items >><<
|
General news
| Commodity prices are… Story temporarily locked. ShowHide Related Items >><<
|
Recommendations
|
Kingfisher price target lowered to EUR 305 from EUR 335 at Deutsche Bank »
12:14 07/05/22 07/0512:14 07/05/2212:14
KGFHY
Kingfisher
Deutsche Bank analyst… Story temporarily locked. ShowHide Related Items >><<
|